| Away Team | Score | Home Team | Score | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hiram | 59 | Oberlin | 86 | |
| Clarkson | 68 | Bard | 56 | |
| Elmira | 51 | Alfred | 71 | |
| WPI | 53 | Middlebury | 49 | |
| Maranatha Baptist | 55 | Martin Luther | 80 | |
| Skidmore | 65 | William Smith | 52 | |
| Hartwick | 56 | Utica | 62 | |
| Houghton | 75 | Keuka | 51 | |
| RIT | 48 | Ithaca | 58 | |
| Vassar | 61 | Union (NY) | 47 | |
| Bates | 73 | St. Joseph's (ME) | 72 | |
| Gettysburg | 70 | Muhlenberg | 35 | |
| Trinity (CT) | 66 | Mitchell | 38 | |
| Haverford | 59 | McDaniel | 46 | |
| Pacific (OR) | 73 | Linfield | 52 | |
| Rockford | 59 | Aurora | 74 | |
| Edgewood | 59 | Benedictine (IL) | 55 | |
| Wells | 33 | SUNY Morrisville | 78 | |
| Pratt | 0 | Bry. & Strat. (Syr.) | 0 | |
| St. Norbert | 47 | Wis. Lutheran | 50 | |
| Marian (WI) | 64 | MSOE | 71 | |
| Dominican (IL) | 68 | Illinois Tech | 62 | |
| Texas Lutheran | 70 | Schreiner | 64 | |
| Penn College | 60 | Penn St.-Abington | 69 | |
| Bryn Mawr | 16 | Washington Col. | 69 | |
| Dickinson | 68 | Ursinus | 53 | |
| Lancaster Bible | 48 | St. Mary's (MD) | 54 | |
| SUNY Potsdam | 0 | SUNY Canton | 0 |