| Away Team | Score | Home Team | Score | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paul Smiths | 0 | SUNY Canton | 0 | |
| La Roche | 55 | Carnegie Mellon | 68 | |
| Carleton | 52 | Saint Benedict | 67 | |
| Millikin | 87 | Eureka | 43 | |
| Mary Washington | 64 | Widener | 61 | |
| Plattsburgh St. | 75 | Clarkson | 81 | |
| CWRU | 86 | Hilbert | 47 | |
| WestConn | 45 | VTSU Castleton | 68 | |
| Franklin & Marshall | 48 | Messiah | 63 | |
| Rhodes | 71 | Hendrix | 64 | |
| Hamilton | 50 | Utica | 56 | |
| Concordia (TX) | 59 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 66 | |
| Cazenovia | 23 | Medaille | 65 | |
| Wesleyan (GA) | 28 | LaGrange | 84 | |
| Penn College | 66 | Mount Aloysius | 51 | |
| Stevenson | 50 | Elizabethtown | 65 | |
| Lebanon Valley | 33 | Moravian | 44 |