| Away Team | Score | Home Team | Score | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fredonia | 40 | Canisius | 106 | |
| Colorado Col. | 54 | CSU Bakersfield | 99 | |
| Thiel | 60 | Lake Erie | 96 | |
| Mary Washington | 78 | Randolph | 76 | |
| Misericordia | 63 | Immaculata | 80 | |
| Pfeiffer | 67 | Va. Wesleyan | 64 | |
| Clarks Summit | 58 | King's (PA) | 78 | |
| Defiance | 75 | Penn St.-Shenango | 79 | |
| Old Westbury | 99 | Medgar Evers | 95 | |
| Beloit | 67 | Marian (WI) | 102 | |
| Valley Forge | 84 | Centenary (NJ) | 104 | |
| Lycoming | 75 | Susquehanna | 56 | |
| Utica | 81 | Cazenovia | 59 | |
| Hartwick | 54 | Skidmore | 71 |