| Away Team | Score | Home Team | Score | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SUNY Canton | 65 | Clarkson | 78 | |
| St. John Fisher | 85 | Utica | 69 | |
| SAGU American Indian | 51 | Lancaster Bible | 107 | |
| Northwestern-St. Paul | 79 | Grace (IN) | 76 | |
| Arcadia | 84 | Alvernia | 82 | |
| Messiah | 66 | FDU-Florham | 57 | |
| Albright | 82 | Lebanon Valley | 77 | |
| Thiel | 60 | Westminster (PA) | 101 | |
| Grove City | 91 | Geneva | 85 | |
| Spalding | 61 | Blackburn | 69 |