| Away Team | Score | Home Team | Score | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| St. John Fisher | 83 | Nazareth | 62 | |
| Webster | 86 | Blackburn | 90 | |
| Elmira | 57 | Houghton | 59 | |
| Aurora | 61 | Lake Forest | 58 | |
| Thiel | 69 | Wash. & Jeff. | 64 | |
| Franciscan | 78 | Westminster (PA) | 99 | |
| Saint Vincent | 62 | Geneva | 94 | |
| Chatham | 57 | Grove City | 78 | |
| Fisher | 61 | Eastern Nazarene | 101 |