๐Ÿปโฌ‡๏ธ๐Ÿ€

2004-2005 NCAAM Model Performance

Scope

All scored games in the selected league and season. AP Poll is excluded here.

Every ranked model predicted the same 3964 games (2004-12-07 to 2005-04-04, 17 weekly windows) out of sample: each week's games were predicted by models fit only on the season's earlier games.

Does recruiting help team predictions?
Men: yes, mostly early. Adding freshman recruiting rankings to the preseason estimate makes Elo's game predictions better by 6.6 milli-nats per game in weeks 1-4 (95% CI 4.2 to 9.1) and by 3.1 over the full season (2.3 to 3.9), on six seasons it never saw; in 2025-26, also unseen, by 10.0 and 3.7. Picks right in weeks 1-4: 76.3% with recruiting, 76.0% without, 74.6% carrying last season over.
Milli-nats: 0.001 of log loss per game, lower is better. Recruiting model report · Preseason prior backtest

Model Catalog · Player models · Preseason prior backtest (team Elo with and without the player-based start)

Model Performance Leaderboard

Ranked by full-season AUC. The final week is the season's last 7 played days (6 games, 2005-03-29 to 2005-04-04), predicted from every earlier game: a small sample that shows the latest form.

# Model AUC Acc Brier LogLoss AUC final wk Acc final wk
1 Margin Recency Margin Recency Margin regression with exponential recency weights on newer games. More โ†’ 0.812 72.3% 0.181 0.541 0.556 66.7%
2 Margin Margin Linear team-strength model fit on point differential instead of binary wins. More โ†’ 0.812 72.5% 0.181 0.541 0.556 66.7%
3 Points Off/Def Recency Points Off/Def Recency Off/def points regression with exponential recency weights. More โ†’ 0.809 72.5% 0.182 0.543 0.556 66.7%
4 Points Off/Def Points Off/Def Raw points regression with separate offensive and defensive team parameters. More โ†’ 0.809 72.5% 0.182 0.544 0.556 66.7%
5 Adjusted Context Blend Adjusted Context Blend Chronologically trained component blend with rest and signed venue context. More โ†’ 0.798 72.4% 0.188 0.563 0.444 50.0%
6 Core Ensemble Core Ensemble Equal-logit blend of Elo, recency BT, recency margin, log-adjusted pyth, and points off/def. More โ†’ 0.795 71.6% 0.186 0.549 0.556 50.0%
7 Recency Ensemble Recency Ensemble Equal-logit blend of Elo, recency BT, recency margin, log-adjusted pyth, and recency points off/def. More โ†’ 0.795 71.7% 0.186 0.549 0.556 50.0%
8 Elo Elo Streaming paired-comparison rating with recency baked into sequential updates. More โ†’ 0.793 71.3% 0.186 0.546 0.444 50.0%
9 Adjusted Efficiency Adjusted Efficiency Opponent-adjusted efficiency model with separate offensive and defensive components. More โ†’ 0.775 69.9% 0.199 0.584 0.778 66.7%
10 Log Adjusted Log Adjusted Log-scale adjusted efficiency model that downweights blowout leverage. More โ†’ 0.775 69.9% 0.199 0.585 0.778 66.7%
11 Dynamic Bradley-Terry Dynamic Bradley-Terry Time-evolving paired-comparison model with latent team strength drift. More โ†’ 0.758 68.6% 0.200 0.584 0.444 50.0%
12 Bradley-Terry Recency Bradley-Terry Recency Static Bradley-Terry with exponential recency weights on newer games. More โ†’ 0.754 68.2% 0.202 0.588 0.333 50.0%
13 Bradley-Terry Bradley-Terry Static logistic paired-comparison model with one team strength parameter. More โ†’ 0.753 68.4% 0.202 0.589 0.333 50.0%
14 Avg Margin Baseline Avg Margin Baseline Predict from simple average scoring margin in the training window. More โ†’ 0.748 68.3% 0.204 0.593 0.444 33.3%
15 Pythagorean Pythagorean Pythagorean win expectation from raw points scored and allowed. More โ†’ 0.744 68.2% 0.209 0.604 0.222 33.3%
16 Home Team Baseline Home Team Baseline Always favor the home team with a fixed prior. More โ†’ 0.657 65.7% 0.229 0.650 0.500 50.0%

Methodology

Out-of-sample windows

  • The season is split into 7-day windows ending on its last played day
  • Each window is predicted by models refit on all earlier games of the season
  • The first window starts after 21 days of games
  • Every model is scored on the same games; a model that cannot predict most of them is listed as not compared

Elo / Bradley-Terry

  • Elo: the published league Elo (preseason priors and carryover where configured), frozen at the window start
  • Bradley-Terry: static logistic fit on the earlier games
  • Recency variants weight games with a 120-day half-life in NCAA leagues (keeping the non-conference games that link conferences) and a 30-day half-life in pro leagues

Pythagorean and margin models

  • Raw, adjusted and log-adjusted Pythagorean from scores; efficiency from box-score possessions
  • Margin: ridge regression on point margin with a learned home advantage
  • Ensembles average the log-odds of five families

Baselines

  • Home Team: the home team wins 60% (50% at neutral sites)
  • Avg Margin: the higher average margin so far wins
  • Models should beat these to add value